After his appearance as a witness to a legal document on June 25, 1766, James Hamilton disappears from the known extant records of St. Croix. The date of his departure from St. Croix is not known, but he must have left the island prior to February 1768 when Rachel Faucett died and their children—James Jr. and Alexander Hamilton—were taken in by the Lyttons.
James Hamilton on Tobago?
On January 23, 1771, The Royal Danish American Gazette on St. Croix reported that on the island of Tobago, more than five hundred miles to the south, “the slaves of the Coramantie nation, about 30 in number, . . . attacked Mr. Hamilton’s house” and “wounded three white men desperately, two of whom are since dead. Mr. Hamilton was shot through the thigh, but is recovering.” Alexander Hamilton must have read this report in the paper.
It is often said that this may have been Alexander Hamilton’s father, whose whereabouts at this time are not known.
But this was not James Hamilton. Instead, the injured “Mr. Hamilton” apparently was John Hamilton, the owner of an estate in Riseland, Tobago. Although no first name is ever given for the “Mr. Hamilton” who was injured, that is because John Hamilton was a prominent person on Tobago, a member of the Assembly and Council, and everyone knew that “Mr. Hamilton” referred to John Hamilton. Moreover, only John Hamilton is known to have owned an estate in Riseland. Furthermore, there is no evidence that James Hamilton ever set foot on Tobago.
* I would like to thank Susan Moore (www.susanmooreresearch.co.uk) for locating and photographing at my request the above documents within the collections of the U.K. National Archives.
James Hamilton on Bequia
By 1774, James Hamilton had moved to Bequia, the northernmost and second largest island of the Grenadine Islands. Just seven square miles in size, Bequia sits about 400 miles south-southeast of St. Croix. It was described at the time as “a beautiful and most healthy island” but “deficient in rivers essential to the comfort and satisfaction” of its inhabitants.
On March 1, 1774, James Hamilton acquired Lot No. 18 on Bequia, a 25-acre parcel of land that had been “reserved for poor settlers” on the north shore of the Admiralty or North Bay.
By 1776, according to a map produced that year, James Hamilton had at least three buildings on his property, but these three structures seem to be the same ones that are shown on a 1763 map of the island.
The 1776 map of Bequia also indicates that James Hamilton owned part of the 70-acre Lot No. 9 on the west shore of the Southeast Bay, which had also been set aside “for the use of poor settlers.”
But this map appears to be mistaken. Thirty of No. 9’s seventy acres were granted to James Sempill in March 1774 and another thirty acres were granted to Robert Sempill in April 1775 with the remainder belonging to the King for public use.
Given that sixty acres of Lot No. 9 were owned by the two Sempills with the remainder belonging to the King for public use and there is no record of James Hamilton owning any part of No. 9, it appears that the map is incorrect. Moreover, the map neglects to note James Hamilton’s ownership of No. 18. Clearly, whoever added “Simple & Hamilton” to the list of lots reserved for “poor settlers” had made a mistake. Lot No. 9 should belong to “Sempill & Sempill” and No. 18 to “Hamilton.”
In May 1786, James Sempill sold his 30 acres of land known as Black Bird point on Southeast Bay, i.e., his share of Lot No. 9. James Hamilton signed the deed as a witness. No location was given, but one assumes the deed was made out and witnessed on Bequia. (The below is a copy that was entered into the deed book. Thus, it is not an authentic James Hamilton signature.)
In May 1790, James Hamilton “of the Island of Bequia” sold his 25-acre lot, i.e., Lot No. 18, for 500 pounds current money, or about 270 pounds sterling, and signed the deed transferring ownership. (Again, below is a copy that was entered into the deed book. It is not an authentic James Hamilton signature.)
James Hamilton on St. Vincent
James Hamilton at this time took his money, left Bequia, and moved about ten miles northward to the larger island of St. Vincent.
On June 12, 1793, James Hamilton wrote to his son, Alexander Hamilton, from St. Vincent. Having sold his property on Bequia, James had hoped to join his son on the mainland, but explained that “my bad State of health has prevented my going to Sea at this time being afflicted with a complication of disorders.” On top of this, “the war which has lately broke out between France & England makes it very dengerous going to Sea at this time.” Still, James hoped that peace would soon arrive and “provided it is not too late in the Season I will embark in the first Vessel that Sails for Philadelphia.” This is the only known extant letter from James Hamilton Sr. to Alexander Hamilton.
Although flush with cash from the sale of his land, James Hamilton had expenses and debts that apparently exceeded his income and savings. Between August 1795 and December 1798, Alexander Hamilton paid drafts for his father totaling at least $1,141.25. Alexander Hamilton later noted that his father “was supported…for several years before his death by me.”
The Death of James Hamilton
James Hamilton, the father of Alexander Hamilton, passed away on St. Vincent in 1799 and was buried in St. George’s Cathedral in Kingstown on June 3 of that year.
On July 13, I will be presenting my biggest discovery to date!
For more details and to RSVP, visit http://discoveringhamilton.com/alexander-hamilton-son-of-a-whore/
 In addition to mistakenly giving the date as March 14, 1774, Ron Chernow also wrote that James Hamilton acquired “woodland property along the shore of Southeast Bay.” As will be seen below, Chernow mixed up this property with another that was mistakenly attributed to James Hamilton. (Chernow, Alexander Hamilton 40.)
 Chernow, who first wrote about James Hamilton on Bequia, did not notice this error and wrote that James Hamilton shared “seventy acres with a man named Simple” (Chernow, Alexander Hamilton 40 and 734).
© Posted on June 25, 2018, by Michael E. Newton. Please cite this blog post when writing about these new discoveries.